Chiefs’ Shocking Draft Pick: Next Mahomes or Biggest Bust?
In a move that has left fans, analysts, and the NFL community buzzing, the Kansas City Chiefs have made a surprising selection in the 2025 NFL Draft, choosing quarterback Jalen Milroe from Alabama with their first-round pick. This decision, taken with the 31st overall pick, has sparked an intense debate: Is Milroe the next Patrick Mahomes, ready to continue the Chiefs’ dynasty, or could he be one of the draft’s biggest busts?
Jalen Milroe, known for his dual-threat capabilities, led Alabama with a blend of arm strength and mobility that has drawn comparisons to Mahomes. His ability to extend plays, make off-script throws, and rush for significant yardage has Chiefs fans dreaming of another era of quarterback excellence. However, the path from college standout to NFL star is fraught with challenges, and Milroe’s draft by the Chiefs has raised eyebrows due to several key factors.
Firstly, the Chiefs already have Patrick Mahomes, arguably the best quarterback in the league, under contract for years to come. The selection of Milroe suggests the team is planning beyond Mahomes or perhaps looking to groom a successor or a high-caliber backup. This foresight could be seen as strategic genius, ensuring the team’s quarterback position remains strong for the foreseeable future. However, it also poses questions about immediate team needs versus long-term planning, especially when other positions, like the offensive line or wide receiver, could have been addressed to better support Mahomes now.
Milroe’s college stats are impressive but come with caveats. His completion percentage has been inconsistent, and his decision-making under pressure has been criticized. While these issues are not uncommon among young quarterbacks adjusting to the NFL, they highlight potential areas where Milroe could struggle. The transition from college to the NFL, especially under the bright lights of Kansas City where expectations are sky-high, could either forge Milroe into a star or expose him to harsh scrutiny.
On the positive side, Milroe’s raw talent is undeniable. His physical attributes, including his size at 6’2″ and 220 pounds, combined with his arm strength and agility, paint a picture of a quarterback with immense potential. Under the tutelage of Andy Reid, one of the best offensive minds in football, Milroe could develop into a quarterback who mirrors Mahomes’ improvisational style but brings his unique flair to the position.
However, there’s a historical precedent of first-round quarterback picks not panning out as expected. For every success story like Mahomes, there are tales of caution. The Chiefs’ gamble on Milroe could either prove to be a masterstroke, adding depth and future security at the most important position, or a misstep if Milroe fails to adapt to the professional level or if the team’s current needs are neglected.
The Chiefs’ front office, led by General Manager Brett Veach, has a history of bold moves that have paid off, but this pick will be scrutinized more than most. Whether Jalen Milroe becomes the next Patrick Mahomes or one of the draft’s biggest busts hinges on development, opportunity, and perhaps a bit of luck. As the season approaches, all eyes will be on Kansas City to see if this shocking draft pick was a visionary choice or a costly mistake.
